Which Is Harder To Master Piano Or Guitar? Guitar vs. Piano
Since the notes on a piano echo in the same sequence over all keys, it is easier for a beginner to remember and memorize them. To make it much simpler, most piano teachers will begin by teaching only the white keys (a total of 7) to adults and all black keys to children (a total of 5).
Since you’ve learned those, you should go on to the rest of the notes. Beginners may also find it easier to understand musical rhythms on a piano. When the notes on a sheet of music shift backward, you’re going to the left over the piano keys. The measurable distances between notes, known as intervals, are very easy to classify. This makes playing pattern-based songs smoother during the first month of lessons.
Since each string has a different arrangement of strings, note patterns on the guitar are a little more complicated. When the pitch changes, it’s even more difficult for a novice to decide which string to use.
The guitar, unlike a piano, needs tuning before playing, which is another hurdle students must overcome rapidly. They will only be allowed to tune once a week when they visit their guitar instructor if they do not do so.
Table of Contents
You Face A Few Additional Challenges While Playing The Guitar:
1) As previously said, in order to make any sound at all, you must both finger a string at a certain fret AND select it at the very same time. As a result, playing easily becomes a serious task because you must accurately plan two very separate tasks.
2) Instead of a single scale of notes as on a piano, there are six strings, each tuned to a different scale. As a result, the 5th fret note on one string differs from the 5th fret note on another string. It’s like playing on six keyboards at once, each of which can only play one note at a time, so you stack them really tightly together to form chords.
Each keyboard is tuned to a different scale of pitches, and you must create chords by bridging over several keyboards at the same time with your fingers placed across them. That’s incredible!
3) Several chord structures exist in the same register due to the uniquely tuning strings. They do, though, have distinct tones. For example, there are seven different variations of a C-major chord that come to mind.
Each one has a distinct voice. This is why reading music composed for piano and wind instruments in conventional “ordinary notation” is extremely difficult for guitarists. Since wind instruments only play one note at a time and do not play chords, this is not a concern.
To make chords, pianos play several notes, but each keyboard has just one scale. And the notes are all in the right order. Guitars have six strings, six scales, and the last two are also offset. Standard notation for guitar does not make sense since the chord notes are vague and can be played in a variety of ways, all of which sound distinctive.
As a result, they used so-called “chord charts” for several years. There are tiny representations of called chords that show which strings and frets are used. While it is still used, the majority of recorded music is now written in “Tabulature,” or TAB for short.
Since there are horizontal lines lined up in bars, with notes and rests, etc., it resembles regular notation. except for the fact that the notes are numbers and the horizontal lines are strings. The guitar’s six strings. The numbers on the fretboard indicate the number of frets. And there’s a whole bunch of symbols that reflect things you can do with a guitar that you can’t do with a piano.
As a result, the traditional piano notation does not allow for these components.
4) Guitars are sometimes returned to a new tuning, which affects all of the notes on every string and frets. You must learn all new chords and none of the old ones make sense. It’s as if you’re mastering a brand new instrument.
Imagine sitting down at a piano and seeing all the notes that came out when you played the keys jumbled. So if you pressed a C, you’d get an A, and if you pressed an F, you’d get a B, and a B is an A, a G is a C, and so on. Consider how none of the chords make sense anymore.
Alternate tunings on a guitar are similar to that. It can seem insane, but people do it to get unique sounds from their instruments. Deeper, janglier tones, resonant sounds, odd chord sounds, and so on. Both of them are extremely interpretive and musically inventive.
On the songs on my acoustic album “Natural Light,” I used four different tunings. EADGBE is the standard, followed by CGCGGC, CGCF#GC, and DADF#AD. As you would expect, the regular notation doesn’t fit well in this situation, but TAB does.
You literally have a legend indicating the tuning of the six strings. As a result, you can write in TAB in any tuning and you never have to remember the names of the notes. It’s not in the names of the notes. It doesn’t matter what key you’re in or how many sharps and flats there are in that key. It’s all about fret and string placement.
5) There’s even fretboard fingering to consider. And if you finger the correct string and fret and pick it at the same time, you can not hear it, or the sound may die easily with a “thunk” sound. This is because there is a slew of ‘touch’ problems surrounding how to play and sound the guitar strings.
It’s not just a hammer striking a string, with each string producing a distinct sound (like a harp). No, fretting and fingering tactics are crucial here. To allow the fret to become the string’s terminal point and thus produce a clean, resonant tone, you must press firmly down on the string just behind the fret.
Often, do not pick the note slightly before or after you finger it – this induces slurring which reduces the note’s lifetime. Alternatively, there may be no note at all. You ought to be PERFECTLY in harmony.
Often, based on the angle of the finger, the roll of it, the nail, the meat of it, the flatness of it, and so on, how your finger on the fingerboard makes a difference. Can you recall the game ‘Twister’? For the finger placements, certain chords remind me of that.
Multiple fingers on the fingerboard in ‘Twister’ mode (to make a chord) poses further difficulties – how to strike the correct note with enough pressure while not touching any other notes or strings, or brushing them and dampening them.
This is where it gets tricky. Especially because you not only have to play this chord while keeping all of these considerations in mind, but you also have to play it quickly in a sequence of chords as part of a moving progression.
6) You’ll also need to learn how to dampen strings that shouldn’t be detected while encouraging other stings to echo through. There are specialized methods that can be used using either the right or left hand, depending on the circumstances.
7) There is also a variety of picking methods to consider. When playing the piano, all you have to do is press the key with your finger, which activates the hammer, which strikes the string. To get dynamics on a given note, you can strike it hard or soft.
On the guitar, there is definitely hitting it hard and gentle, holding a note for a long time or keeping it short, but there is also down picking, up-stroking, circle-picking, sweep-picking, fingerpicking (different types – Merle Travis, Chet Atkins, Jerry Reed, Banjo-style, Classical, etc. ), finger-plucking/pulling, and finger-plucking/pulling, to name a few.
There are hammer-ons and pull-offs (both single-handed and two-handed), alternating picking, smooth legato-style, palm-muffling as you downstroke, and more. Picking on the note is followed by bending up. There’s a note about picking on the up-bend and then settling back down to rest. Sliding into the note from the fret above or below is possible. There are pinch and tap-harmonics of a note, as well as various techniques for each, and so on.
8) Picking with picks, fingertips, nails, and variations of picks and fingers (for the bass string side) and fingers (for the treble string side).
9) And then there’s the whole vibrato thing. If you flex your hand to get it with a repeated semi rotation (my friend Neil Doherty has a natural talent for this, but I’ve never been able to do it with my left hand for some reason), or do it back and forth from the wrist Techniques for tremolo bars, etc.
There are a variety of ways to play a note on a guitar, and they all depend on the feel. The artist’s personality and attention to the guitar’s operation and response. This is why it has the potential to be a sensual instrument.
Since your fingertips are actually touching the strings, your approach, touch, and feelings are directly converted into the sound that emerges, allowing you to be very articulate about how you play until you get the hang of it. Take, for example, my most recent single, “Goodbye.” Hopefully, that gives you an idea of what I’m talking about.
10) There’s also the world of guitar sound effects and how to use them when playing the instrument. There is no piano counterpart, but synthesizers will come close. However, certain effects, such as a wah pedal, a volume pedal, or a voice box, as well as simple effects like sweep flangers, swell, auto wah, and compressor, are important not just in how it sounds, but also in how you play it.
11) And there’s slide guitar and all the tricks that go with it. Any could be behind the slide when playing variations of fretted notes with the slide. To fit the slide, different tunings were used. Muting with other fingers, plucking the strings, slide playing with fingerpicks, and so on. This is a whole different art style.
Piano Or Guitar
As compared to the piano, the guitar has a very different conceptual concept. The piano is both faster and more difficult to play than the guitar. The below are a few examples of how the piano can be more difficult to play:
1) You’re attempting to do two tasks at once. With the left hand, you play one chord or melody by using the right hand to play another. That is a difficult task! On the guitar, it’s not unheard of, but it’s extremely difficult. This was something that Chet Atkins and Andre Segovia were known for.
I’ve done it myself on occasion, but it takes a lot of preparation and commitment due to the unique difficulties that the guitar presents by its very existence. However, this is something that any pianist does. It’s basically how the music is played, and as a guitarist, I find it magical and amazing – as well as the most difficult aspect.
2) Instead of playing six notes at a time as on a guitar, you should play ten notes at a time.
3) Because it is such a high-fidelity instrument that covers so much of the musical spectrum, you are usually responsible for much more of the overall sound.
4) There are some very complicated piano compositions in some classical music. On file, there are a couple of black notes. And if it involves various melodies and rhythms on each side at the same time, you are supposed to play it all.
In the following regions, though, the piano is simpler to play than the guitar:
1) All of the notes are in a straightforward series from low to high. There are no holes or skips. It follows a set of rules. The notes are in order from A to G, like sharps and flats. All is in the same location where you would like it to be.
2) The main sequence is repeated. What works in one octave can be repeated in the next octave without losing its effectiveness.
3) To make a sound, you just need to do one thing. You make a keystroke. One finger, on one hand, can make a sound, but two fingers cannot work together to produce a single sound. It is easier to play quicker on a piano than on a guitar without the two-handed coordination needed for each note.
Consider what it would be like if you had to play all in octave unison to get some sound out at all. Imagine that the notes on your right hand were to be played on your left hand as well and that you had to be able to click the key at EXACTLY the same time in order for just one note to be played. What kind of speed would you be able to play at then? (That’s how you play lead on the guitar.) It’s much more difficult than that, for reasons I’ll discuss later.)
4) It is activated by a mechanical mechanism. A piano is a stringed instrument, but unlike most stringed instruments such as guitars, harps, and lutes (with the exception of the hammer-dulcimer), the player seldom touches the strings.
From a guitarist’s view, you don’t really “sing” the piano. Rather, you use KEYS to control hammers and then pound on the strings to produce the sounds. They always struck the right notes on the right chords, and they always did so in the same manner. The only things you need to know about playing it are how soft or heavy you hit the keys, how long you keep them down, and whether or not you use the sustain pedal.
However, playing the piano is not easy. Any way
As I previously said, playing the piano is not for the faint of heart. It still has its drawbacks. The two instruments aren’t the same. The guitar has a smaller range and is played by simply pressing the strings, which offers many possibilities but also many challenges and necessitates a variety of techniques, while the piano is bigger, more expansive, and demands a variety of techniques.
Since it is simple to create chords and sounds on a piano, but difficult to play the vast sounds and complex melodies that occur in some of the more demanding piano music, the problems usually come from the music itself rather than the shortcomings of the instrument, because it is easy to make chords and sounds on a piano, but difficult to play the vast sounds and complex melodies that exist in some of the more challenging piano music.
I hope I haven’t offended any pianists with this! Someone who can play the piano well still impresses me. – I’d like to read it! I’d do it if I just had the opportunity.
Immediate gratification
Piano lessons offer a greater sense of immediate pleasure. It’s simply easier to play a note if you sit up straight, raise your wrists, softly curl your fingers, and click a key. Granted, playing the piano becomes more difficult as you progress and begin to play rhythmically isolated notes with various fingers and hands. In the beginning, playing the guitar needs more coordination.
Beginner piano students can not use two hands right away so they must learn how to pluck and fret the string at the same time without dampening the pitch.
The learning curve for piano students will slow down while they improve the balance required to use both hands on the keys to perform various chords and melodies. Playing the guitar becomes better over time as students understand chords and master more songs faster than a piano player.
However, since each pupil has differing learning skills, this is debatable. The student’s enthusiasm for the instrument is also a deciding factor in how quickly and effectively they can master it.
How to Learn to Read Music
Piano teachers typically have a systematic foundation of music theory and how to interpret music, while both guitar and piano lessons provide a greater platform for learning to read and understand music than, say, singing lessons.
Guitar teachers, on the other hand, may begin with a beginner’s book, but after a few months, they often transition to teaching by ear and example. Classical guitar lessons are an exception since students practice by graded lesson books and must pass RCM exams.
For other guitar lesson forms, you may also request that your teacher incorporate music theory and note reading into your lessons; a good teacher would gladly comply.
Last Thought Which Is Harder To Master Piano Or Guitar
The piano is an outstanding place to start for children. It gives more immediate excitement for the first few music classes, breaks up the music philosophy, and also provides a base on which they will later tackle any instrument, including the guitar.
It all comes down to personal preference when it comes to choosing between piano and guitar lessons. In the grand scheme of things, these are all minor factors, particularly as compared to other instruments.
Do you like immediate pleasure while playing the piano, with all of your keys set out in front of you like a musical map? Or are you able to put in a bit more effort to easily memorize the fretboard so you can shred on an electric guitar?
Piano and guitar are similarly capable of supplying the fundamentals of music that other musicians, such as drums or voice, lack. They’re both great beginner instruments that take you down different pathways to the same goal: to love music and maybe one day become a skilled musician.